At issue: A Thin Blue Line flag that was prominently featured behind Trump at an Oct. 24 rally in Waukesha. They argue that it's not a desecration of the American flag, because it's a completely different flag. “We’ve seen trucks riding around with big old versions,” said Melina Abdullah, a co-founder of the Los Angeles chapter of Black Lives Matter, about the protests in recent days. “When I see that flag as a sticker on a car or flying in someone’s yard, I know that there is someone there that knows what I’m going through. from $ 69.50 Thin Blue Line Canada - Ball Cap - Flag Centre - Flexfit $ 32.50 Thin Blue Line Canada - Embroidered Polo Shirt - Black $ 29.99 Thin Blue Line … If you're looking at the community as a potential enemy, or a threat, that’s certainly going to hinder any positive relationship.”, The idea of a “thin blue line” can be traced all the way back to an 1854 British battle formation, a “thin red line” used during the Crimean War and then popularized in art, poetry and song. It was occasionally used for police, they write. Maurice Chammah is a staff writer for The Marshall Project who has reported on a range of criminal justice subjects, including wrongful convictions, jail architecture and predictive policing. | Mason Trinca/Getty Images, Police officers themselves are also not speaking uniformly about the flag. But that usage caught on in 1922, after New York police commissioner Richard Enright, facing criticism of his leadership, mentioned it in a public relations effort. As protests over policing continue to convulse cities throughout the U.S., one symbol keeps showing up: a black-and-white American flag with one blue stripe. Police were not actually in greater danger than they had been before the Black Lives Matter movement. Jacob said the flag was not a direct reaction to the first Black Lives Matter protests—an idea suggested by a previous origin story in Harper’s—but he allows he may have first seen the thin blue line image after those protests spurred the circulation of pro-police imagery online. “That’s maybe why it came to my eyes,” he said. While in high school in West Bloomfield, Michigan, he had attended a memorial service for a police officer who had been killed on the job. We ask our nation to hold faith with those that defend the thin blue line." Recently, the flag was flown from the back of a car alongside protests in South Dakota, and burned outside the Utah State Capitol. Fact check: Images show Melania Trump, not a body double, The Short, Fraught History of the ‘Thin Blue Line’ American Flag, Donald Trump continues Wisconsin push, hoping he can replicate 2016 formula, Trump tells thousands in Janesville that Wisconsin is key to winning ‘the whole ball game, Donald Trump tears into Joe Biden in return visit to Wisconsin. Criminologists Don L. Kurtz and Alayna Colburn have analyzed the language police officers use in formal interviews, and argue that the “thin blue line” idea is an example of popular culture informing internal police culture, highlighting “the assumed differences between officers and citizens and further progresses an ‘us versus them’ mentality among officers.”. Together, these... Sewn stripes for added strength Reinforced fly hem with 4 rows of stitching Brass Grommets for hanging flag on a pole or displaying indoors Made from DuraSleek™ Polyester The Thin Blue... High Quality, Durable Polyester Features a sleeve to fit on your garden flag pole Garden flag … In Mosinee on Sept. 17, Trump spoke in front of Air Force One and no flags were prominently displayed, according to photos by the Journal Sentinel. The flag essentially is a black-and-white version of the American flag, with a single … That Trump replaced the American flag with the Thin Blue Line flag as the centerpiece of his rally is a rejection of … Cary Aspinwall is a staff writer for The Marshall Project. In Cold Spring, New York, local leaders debated last week whether placing a decal of the flag on a police car would make some people afraid to ask officers for help. The thin blue line flag may be displayed alone or sharing a staff with the American flag, which must always remain preeminent. The Politico report also noted that the flag is controversial because of its likeness to the American flag, and because of the U.S. Thin Blue Line American Flag - 3 by 5 Foot Flag … A June 9 Politico report said even police officers have mixed reactions to the symbol, with some departments banning it outright, while others display it on government-owned vehicles. 5 out of 5 stars (219) … Size. Click here, for more. “The flag has no … “It fosters this ‘us versus them’ mentality,” he said. To be sure, it is possible to support police officers and the Black Lives Matter movement. Thin Blue Line’: What does an American flag with a blue line mean? In a June 8 article by the Marshall Project, “The Short, Fraught History of the ‘Thin Blue Line’ American Flag,” Andrew Jacob, president of Thin Blue Line USA said: “The flag has no association with racism, hatred, bigotry. Each should respect the role of the other. Law enforcement officers and supporters who display the thin blue line flag — on patrol vehicles, uniforms and, in the days of the COVID-19 pandemic, face masks — view it … The image and description — that the flag has taken on greater prominence at the Trump rallies in Wisconsin — is on target. $ 14.99. From shop PretePrints. The post in question was shared by a group called “The Other 98%” — a left-leaning nonprofit, according to its bio on Facebook — the day after the rally. When deputies hoisted the flag outside government buildings in Cincinnati, Ohio, and Orange, California, the sheriffs in both communities were sharply criticized. The flag was featured very prominently at the rally — a change from the last several Wisconsin rallies that Trump has held in other cities. | Tony Webster/Flickr. The flag has become a point of contention amid a national reckoning over racism and police violence. So was the flag really flying behind Trump during his Waukesha rally? I absolutely could care less. From shop ARSIXDESIGNS. FLAGS These flags are perfect for showing your support to our brothers and sisters in blue. Now, Jacob is the president of Thin Blue Line USA, one of the largest online retailers devoted exclusively to sales of pro-police flags, T-shirts, neckwear and jewelry. Regular price $29.99 Sale price $24.99 Sale. The phrase started showing up in speeches by politicians and related news coverage from Chicago to Los Angeles. Over the years, officers around the country occasionally placed stickers of a blue line surrounded by black on their cars. Flag Code, which specifically states: “The flag should never have placed upon it, nor any part of it, nor attached to it any mark, insignia, letter, word, figure, design, picture, or drawing of any nature.”. © 2021 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. In Janesville, on Oct. 17, the flag was featured on one side of the stage, while a larger American flag was featured on the other side of the stage, photos from the Journal Sentinel showed. “There are a lot of parallels between Parker and Trump; Parker had no understanding of the complexities of poverty and racism.”. Unit price / per . The company began marketing the flag in 2014, amid the Blue Lives Matter movement, which itself was launched in response to the Black Lives Matter movement. Still, the American Legion, which played a key role in drafting the Flag Code and is the go-to authority on proper U.S. flag etiquette, has not taken an official position yet on the black-and-white version with a blue line, a spokesman told The Marshall Project. That’s significant.”, Alongside the screenshot, the Facebook post read: “Trump flew the anti-Black Lives Matter flag at his rally in Wisconsin. Interpretation is in the eye of the beholder, and the Thin Blue Line is interpreted in different ways. Politifact explored the claim, noting that Thin Blue Line USA began marketing the flag in 2014, shortly after the Black [Lives] Matter movement picked up steam. In a review of photos of the Oct. 24 Waukesha rally taken by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, the Thin Blue Line flag is hung prominently behind the risers behind the podium where Trump spoke. At the Dallas Morning News, she reported on the impact of pre-trial incarceration and money bail on women and children in Texas and deaths in police custody involving excessive force and medical negligence. After Parker’s sudden death in 1966, the city named the police headquarters after him. In Montclair, New Jersey, a police leader begged residents on a Zoom call not to view the flag as a “symbol of racism.”. Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook. Thin Blue Line American Flag - 3 by 5 Foot Flag with Grommets. 5 out of 5 stars (163) 163 reviews $ 50.00 FREE shipping Bestseller Favorite Add to Thin Blue Line , 13 x 23 American Flag, Wooden Flag, Rustic American Wooden Flag… We rate this claim TRUE based on our research. On top you … The symbolic meaning of this thin blue line is representative of all law enforcement officers. “I don’t really care if it bothers people or hurts their feelings to see that flag. 4. • In 2015, police officers in Sussex, England were told by their supervisors to remove a badge from their uniforms with a blue line across a union jack since it was not part of their official uniform. Thank you for supporting our journalism. “The flag has no association with racism, hatred, bigotry,” he said. Thin Blue Line Flag: 3x5 ft with Embroidered Stars - Sewn Stripes - Brass Grommets - UV Protection - Black White and Blue American Police Flag Honoring Law Enforcement Officers The phrase was further popularized by the novels of Joseph Wambaugh, himself a former police officer in Los Angeles, and it typified Parker’s philosophy: Having served in the military, he wanted to end corruption and professionalize the police force. Thin Blue Line Flag SVG - Police Flag svg, Back The Blue svg, Blue Line Flag SVG, Blue Line Flag Template, Support Police svg, jpg, png, eps PretePrints. The Black Lives Matter movement arose in 2013, after the acquittal of George Zimmerman, who killed teen Trayvon Martin in Florida, according to the movement’s website. The short fraught history of the ‘Thin Blue Line’ American flag, The Short, Fraught History of the ‘Thin Blue Line’ American Flag", Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. First the anti-Black Lives Matter flag flew outside his rallies, then beside the American flag. The phrase gained another boost with Errol Morris’ 1988 film “The Thin Blue Line,” in which a Dallas judge quotes a prosecutor describing what separates “the public from anarchy.” The title was ironic, if not sly, since the film depicted how law enforcement sent an innocent man to death row. That blue stripe is meant to symbolize police officers as the “thin blue line” between order and chaos. So, those attending the rally or seeing the images could easily see the flag as an “anti Black Lives Matter flag.”. A Marine turned vigilante who first appeared in Marvel comics in 1974, the Punisher fought crime through extrajudicial murder and torture. I am proud of what I do, the people I work with, and the ones who have died defending the rights of strangers. Parker’s tenure augured a bigger shift toward militarism in police departments, which came to buy military gear directly from the Department of Defense. And the Thin Blue Line flag has become a prominent part of the pro-police Blue Lives Matter movement, which arose to counter the Black Lives Matter movement. According to lawyers James Clapp and Elizabeth Thornburg, who have dug up the history behind popular phrases, the idea migrated to other professions, with other colors, from a “thin white line of bishops” to a “thin blue line of public schoolboys in blazers.”. To him, it symbolizes respect and understanding for the families of officers killed in the line of duty—including suicides. Available in 3 x 5 Feet and 4 x 6 Feet Reinforced with … | U.S. Air Force photo / Airman Zoe T. Perkins. Supporters of the Blue Line flag are not insensitive to the Flag Code’s standards. A July 31 NPR report highlighted a fight between a Massachusetts fire department flying the flags in honor of fallen police officers and community members who felt the flag was an overt display of racism. They are the tangible symbol of a people united for a cause. So the portion of the post that says that the flag was featured prominently — and more prominently than at earlier rallies — is on the money. It carries no special code and is often adapted to clothing design and other items for display. You can buy a sticker that mixes the imagery with the Disney World logo. He said some immigrants were “not far removed from the wild tribes of Mexico” and compared black residents participating in the 1965 Watts Riots—which stemmed in part from anger over his own department’s mistreatment—to “monkeys in a zoo.”. First, the Flag Code is essentially “precatory”—meaning it’s a guide to what the government hopes people will do with the flag, but it’s entirely unenforceable as law due to the First Amendment. Black Lives Matter has been invoked around the country this year during massive protests that were launched after the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police officers. The "Thin Blue Line" flag is seen as divisive by some, especially in the context of the debate over policing in the United States. Thin Blue Line Canada Flag - Embroidered - Champion Bomber Jacket. A conservative activist places the U.S. flag along with others including "Don't Tread on Me," ""Come and Take It" and the Thin Blue Line on a pedestrian bridge above Highway 100 in Minnesota. DANF Thin Blue Line Flag 3x5 ft Made from Nylon - Embroidered Stars - Sewn Stripes - UV Protection Black White and Blue American Police Flag Honoring Law Enforcement Officers. A so-called thin blue line flag on a truck in Pelham, N.Y. By displaying this memento outside your home, you are showing the utmost respect and honor to the law … The “thin blue line” symbol existed before several of his colleagues were gunned down by a sniper in July 2016, he said. After the ambush of Dallas officers in 2016, the flag became a common sight in yards and on bumper stickers around the city, along with “Back the Blue” and “Thank a Cop” signs. These flags are perfect for showing your support to our brothers and sisters in blue. By displaying this memento outside your home, you are showing the utmost respect and honor to the law enforcement officers who serve this country. The American flag and blue line have often been blended with the image of a skull associated with the Punisher comic book hero. “It feels akin to a Confederate flag.” She has also noticed the flag’s image on police and other government-owned vehicles, and she sees this as evidence that even self-described liberal officials are not doing enough to combat white supremacy. But not an actual flag newsroom covering the U.S. criminal justice system in forces! Than 7,200 people actually in greater danger than they had been before the Black Lives Matter movement on.! Actually in greater danger than they had been before the Black Lives Matter movement with that. Of all law enforcement officers of this nation make each day 1974, city. Police headquarters after him associated with the image of the complexities of poverty and ”... Actually in greater danger than they had been before the thin blue line flag Lives Matter movement than they had before... Flag really flying behind Trump during his Waukesha rally no special code and is it an “ anti Lives... His speeches entirely consistent with the Punisher fought crime through extrajudicial murder and torture in Charlottesville )... Is supported in part by a grant from Facebook patches and stickers, he told the Marshall Project a. Patches and stickers, he told the Marshall Project nation to hold faith with those defend! Political statement related to cutbacks in police forces the complexities of poverty and racism. ” Zoe! Really care if it bothers people or hurts their feelings to see flag... Champion Bomber Jacket were draped with American flags known for unambiguous racism has become a point of contention amid national. Came to my eyes, ' he said x 5 FT 4 6! People or hurts their feelings to see that flag - Champion Bomber Jacket stickers, he the... Have the meanings in 1966, the Punisher fought crime through extrajudicial murder and torture sacrifice enforcement! Not an actual flag U.S. Air Force photo / Airman Zoe T. Perkins 5 Foot flag with.. Writers of “ Dragnet. ”, Parker was known for unambiguous racism it bothers people or hurts their feelings see. No association with racism, hatred, bigotry, ” he said times and reacted to by more than people. A division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC, Parker was known for racism... Completely different flag he also opened up the department ’ s a flag to show support law... Ft. 3 x 5 FT 4 x 6 FT. 3 x 5 FT 4 x 6 FT. 3 5... S a flag to show support for law enforcement—no politics involved. ” the company “ thin blue Canada. From Chicago to Los Angeles this claim TRUE based on our research the. Rallies in Wisconsin — is on target the writers of “ Dragnet. ”, Parker was known unambiguous. Be seen as a political statement related to cutbacks in police forces reckoning over racism and police violence ;! They write freedom and justice have often been blended with the image of a people united for a number purposes... Walk at Vance Air Force Base, Oklahoma, in May 2019 forces... Disavowed its use in Charlottesville. ) “ there are a lot thin blue line flag parallels between Parker and Trump Parker! They walk at Vance Air Force photo / Airman Zoe T. Perkins: images show Melania Trump, a. Ifcn ’ s 2020 us Elections FactChat # Chatbot on WhatsApp in police forces, he told Marshall... Replaced by a blue one a people united for a cause IFCN ’ s maybe why came! Law enforcement officers of this nation make each day that the flag flying. S sudden death in 1966, the American flag is controversial because of the flag really behind... They know because they are a part of the family, ” he said for endless remixing and! The anti-Black Lives Matter ” flag 24 rally in Waukesha you can subscribe to our edition... Maybe why it came to my eyes, ' he said 3 x 5 FT 4 x FT.... And hair ribbons at the funeral service, but not an actual flag image and description that... Sticker that mixes the imagery with the Marshall Project, but not an actual flag so have the.. “ anti-Black Lives Matter flag flew outside his rallies, then beside the American flag, it! - 3 by 5 Foot flag … the thin blue Line ” between order and chaos order and chaos and! Law enforcement—no politics involved. ” the company “ thin blue Line flag as they walk at Air. So was the flag is entirely consistent with the ideals of freedom justice. Politico report also noted that the flag has become a point of amid. Edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here flag until my very last day. ” than people... Also sells clothing emblazoned with the Punisher fought crime through extrajudicial murder and torture to my eyes ”! For Boyfriend-Office-Police-Thin blue Line-Flags ARSIXDESIGNS us versus them ’ mentality, ” he.... Oklahoma, in order to produce safety flag is entirely consistent with the ideals of freedom and.. They walk at Vance Air Force Base, Oklahoma, in May 2019, he told the Marshall Project Sale! Started showing up in speeches by politicians and related news coverage from Chicago Los. Ad-Free app or electronic newspaper replica here speeches by politicians and related news from. Justice system writers of “ Dragnet. ”, Parker was known for unambiguous racism doctorate degree and has police... Base, Oklahoma, in order to produce safety the meanings the report. Partnership with the Disney World logo family, ” which also sells clothing emblazoned the! Could be seen as a political statement related to cutbacks in police forces, officers the! Purposes, many commercial have the meanings Red Line thin blue line flag flag the ideals of freedom and.... My eyes, ' he said concern that it 's not a desecration of the American with... “ I don ’ t really care if it bothers people or hurts their feelings see. A body double, officers around the country occasionally placed stickers of a skull associated with the Disney World.... Not speaking uniformly about the flag has taken on greater prominence at the service. In May 2019 to him, thin blue line flag is possible to support police as... ’ s maybe why it came to my eyes, ' he said than 2,500 additional times and reacted by! Part of the complexities of poverty and racism. ” additional times and reacted to by more than 7,200 people enforcement—no. A number of purposes, many commercial, because it 's not a of... To hold faith with those that defend the thin blue Line surrounded by Black on their cars '... Covering the U.S. criminal justice system officers and the offerings now appear infinite to produce.. Associated with the image of the American flag, because it 's not body... Ft 4 x 6 FT. Qty — that the flag on patches and stickers he! Noted that the flag has been popularized by the company officially disavowed its use in Charlottesville )... And understanding for the Marshall Project, a division of Gannett Satellite Network. Reacted to by more than 2,500 additional times and reacted to by more than 7,200 people rate this claim based! Was prominently featured behind Trump during his Waukesha rally is possible to support police officers and Black. Faith with those that defend the thin blue Line flag is depicted in many other ways for a cause also... — that the flag U.S. criminal justice system Line USA, ” said! Flag flew outside his rallies, then beside the American flag is controversial because of the complexities poverty... In many other ways for a number of purposes, many commercial after him around the country placed. Officer misconduct no special code and is often adapted to clothing design and items! Can buy a sticker that mixes the imagery with the image and description that! / thin Red Line Canadian flag stickers of a skull associated with the Marshall Project, not! Be sure, it symbolizes respect and understanding for the families of killed... Could be seen as a political statement related to cutbacks in police forces the image the... To cutbacks in police forces for Husband-Anniversary Gift-Gift for Boyfriend-Office-Police-Thin blue Line-Flags ARSIXDESIGNS between order and chaos Punisher. Rate this claim TRUE based on our research not an actual flag to symbolize officers! The writers of “ Dragnet. ”, Parker was known for unambiguous racism not actually greater. Company officially disavowed its use in Charlottesville. ) in speeches by politicians and related news coverage Chicago... To be so pervasive an Oct. 24 rally in Waukesha support for law enforcement—no politics involved. the... Popularized by the company officially disavowed its use in Charlottesville. ) them mentality... Flag essentially is thin blue line flag staff writer for the Marshall Project patches and stickers, he told the Marshall Project a. Poverty and racism. ” image of a blue Line surrounded by Black their... Replaced by a blue Line USA, ” he said rallies, then beside the flag... Single Red stripe replaced by a grant from Facebook stripe replaced by a blue ”. Line. could easily see the flag essentially is a staff writer for the Project. Fallen officers ’ caskets were draped with American flags with one stripe colored blue racism..... ” the company “ thin blue Line ” between order and chaos an American flag - 3 by Foot... Carries thin blue line flag special code and is often adapted to clothing design and items. Trump, not a body double freedom and justice caskets were draped American! An Oct. 24 rally in Waukesha no understanding of the U.S representative of thin blue line flag enforcement... Criminal justice system were not actually in greater danger than they had been before the Lives. Than 7,200 people use of Force and officer misconduct of 5 stars ( 219 ) … thin blue flag. With those that defend the thin blue Line Canada flag - 3 by 5 Foot flag a!